{"id":283,"date":"2026-11-17T05:06:30","date_gmt":"2026-11-17T05:06:30","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/?p=283"},"modified":"2026-11-17T05:06:32","modified_gmt":"2026-11-17T05:06:32","slug":"brain-the-size-of-a-planet","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/?p=283","title":{"rendered":"Brain the Size of a Planet"},"content":{"rendered":"\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Or<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">How to Design Not-Stupid Jobs<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">OK, I might not have a brain the size of a planet like Marvin \u2014 you know, the robot from The Hitchhiker\u2019s Guide to the Galaxy, for all of you ignorant Vogons \u2014 but he was always the character I felt for most in the story. And no, Douglas, he was not paranoid, he was depressed. And he has every reason to be. Nobody ever uses his potential. He\u2019s ordered around, and nobody asks what he thinks. On top of that, everyone finds him tiresome and leaves him alone. If you\u2019re having a flashback, yes, we\u2019ll get to that.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">But first, how does this relate to work and business and organizations and all that jazz? Well, we\u2019re talking about motivation, or the driving force. More than a hundred years ago, Frederick Winslow Taylor, in his book The Principles of Scientific Management, described workers who, after a long workday, energetically built their own houses each evening and morning. Or how workers enthusiastically played sports in their free time. Or how they walked briskly to and from work. Yet did these workers show the same kind of energy, enthusiasm or speed at work? No, they did not. Somehow the energy that was observable outside of work was suddenly switched off at work. What we will look at in this essay is the thing that turns it off. Humans are curious, active and social by default. The environment \u2014 or the conditions \u2014 they are in either enhances or undermines this. That is just one of the many things Edward L. Deci and Richard M. Ryan stated in their decades-long research on something called SDT \u2014 and yes, it sounds like a sexually transmitted disease, but it actually stands for self-determination theory. Scientists really could do with some marketing support. But joking aside, the ultimate question we want to answer is: what does a job need so the energy stays? The answer is not 42 or anything grand. The answer is jobs that aren\u2019t stupid.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">I mentioned Taylor and his book on purpose. He and his movement \u2014 also called Taylorism \u2014 revolutionized work, or at least how management viewed it at the time. His mission was to make work more productive by studying each individual task: how it was done, finding the most efficient method and training workers to follow his instructions. In his view, that was the role of management, and it would lead to the company lowering its costs while paying workers higher wages. Perfect, right? And so machine thinking got its system. Everybody was just a cog in the big thing, all perfectly fitted and synchronized. And it worked. He had numbers to show for it. And to be really fair to Taylor, he was not a villain. He also planned for workers to have some rest time. But this is also where the real problems start to show. When I think of workers being treated like parts of a big machine, Charlie Chaplin\u2019s Modern Times comes to mind. To me, it\u2019s a good illustration of what Ryan and Deci call the \u201cpassive-organism assumption.\u201d If you make work a machine-like process, you can end up treating people as though they have no active tendencies of their own, as though all their motivation has to come from outside. And the problems go on, because if everything has to come from the outside, constant maintenance is needed. Any productivity gains may only hold as long as the stopwatch, the whip or the bonus stays. In that world \u2014 or work \u2014 view, once the stopwatch is gone, the human would be passively lazy again. So we would need an army of checkers \u2014 and of box tickers and taskmasters, as David Graeber calls them in his book Bullshit Jobs \u2014 to keep the machine running. A whole category of professions needed mainly because we had the wrong view of what humans are \u2014 you know, humans as in you and me and your mother. Graeber\u2019s categories have been empirically tested. Soffia and colleagues found that workers in supposedly pointless jobs do report the alienation he predicts, but in far fewer cases: about 5%, not the 20\u201350% he claimed \u2014 which is still something. They also found that the feeling of uselessness is linked to bad management and poorly designed jobs, not to certain professions. So the problem of machine-designed jobs producing passive workers is documented independently of Graeber\u2019s framework.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Look, we are not just cogs in a machine, right? At least it feels wrong somehow. And your gut feeling is absolutely correct. If I have learned anything from all the philosophy mumbo jumbo in these essays, it\u2019s that the human being is a truly remarkable something. We are intelligent and social and self-determining. We can reason, and we can give ourselves purpose. Hell, we can even group up in organizations and give these organizations a purpose. So why do we still think workers need to be force-fed motivation from the outside? Why do managers to this day still work with the carrot-and-stick method? Why do we still throw money at people in the form of bonuses for reaching some strange KPI that must have been cooked up by Radagast? And why do we still look at work and think it should be designed for a machine? No, not you, Marvin. You are special. And to find out how jobs can be not stupid, we should first look at what we actually need to keep the machine running \u2014 ah, not again.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">With almost fifty years of joint research \u2014 even more if you count their individual work \u2014 and lots of other colleagues, Deci and Ryan accumulated a lot of insight into this question. Sadly, Deci died this past February, but the research continues. I mentioned SDT \u2014 self-determination theory \u2014 before, so here is just a \u201cshort\u201d recap. We have three needs: autonomy, competence and connectedness \u2014 they call it relatedness. Autonomy in the psychological sense is a more modest claim than what Kant would ask for. Psychological autonomy means acting with a sense of choice and endorsing what you are doing, not absolute independence. Competence is the need to feel capable on the one hand and effective on the other. It\u2019s about feeling that you can meet a challenge and get better at something, or see that your work makes a difference. Now, connectedness is the tricky one for me as an introvert. But it doesn\u2019t mean holding hands all the time and singing \u201cKumbaya.\u201d It is merely the feeling of being cared for and of contributing.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">When all of these needs are met, people are more likely to do something because they find it interesting or enjoy it \u2014 enjoy work? Crazy, right? This is what Deci and Ryan call intrinsic motivation.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Now, these needs are objective; they cannot be negotiated away. There can of course be additional subjective goals, but the three basic needs are true for everybody, even for Marvin. And that is why he is so depressed. Because these needs don\u2019t just have to do with motivation. SDT is bigger than that. It also explains a lot about what is beneficial or harmful to your mental health. If any of the needs are not met, your mental health is at risk. And these three needs being \u201cuniversal\u201d also means that if you need to assess tasks, jobs and management styles, you get an all-in-one toolkit. Managers don\u2019t need to analyze individual types of people. But be careful: this only goes for the basics of motivation. There are other subjects, such as communication, health needs, career goals or training, that require individual analysis and handling of employees.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">But it is not just an on-or-off thing \u2014 controlled vs. autonomous. It is more of a continuum. And the quality of the motivation has more to do with its effect on people than the amount. Actually, stuff from the outside \u2014 or extrinsic \u2014 can be quite autonomous if done correctly. Even working for pay, the classic extrinsic reward, can under the right circumstances be experienced as autonomous, but let\u2019s get to that later.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The fact is that rules \u2014 as something coming from the outside, something controlling \u2014 are real and sometimes, or mostly, or often important. Or as Deci and Ryan put it: \u201cSocialized life is not all fun and games.\u201d Yet there are differences in how I react to rules: external, introjected, identified and integrated. External is what you would think \u2014 I do it because I get a reward or want to avoid a penalty. Introjected is because I pressure myself \u2014 through guilt or shame or stupid stuff like that. Identified is because I see the value in it. And integrated because it fits with my own values and sense of who I am. Obviously, the first hurts your autonomy most, and so on. Now, just to be clear on the wording \u2014 this is all still extrinsic motivation, but if you integrate a rule, it will not hurt your sense of autonomy. This depends largely not on the rule itself \u2014 as long as it is somewhat logical, of course \u2014 but on how it is brought to me. So if somebody just tells me to do something, it tends to stay external. If somebody explains to me why it makes sense, and I understand it, it tends to become identified. This distinction is not just important for me as an individual but also for the effectiveness of the rule. Studies have shown that identified and integrated rules stick without being constantly checked. So don\u2019t just tell people to wear safety shoes; explain to them why it is important, and maybe also show them a picture of what a foot looks like after being squished by a 200 kg pallet. Identified and integrated rules make sense to people, they feel good about following them, and you reach your goal without constantly checking.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Rules usually apply at the task level, but what about jobs? It gets a bit more complicated, but a lot of work has gone into how to make jobs not stupid \u2014 although the serious people call it job enrichment. That is serious enrichment, not the slogan type. But let\u2019s first finish this part by adding a couple of more serious notes on why this is so important. And I have to bring Marvin back one more time. He is such a poor fellow because none of his three needs are met, and he is depressed. He does all of the stupid tasks he is asked to do \u2014 he delivers the right output \u2014 but he is a wrecked person. Why has this become a tragic situation that a lot of non-robots \u2014 as in humans \u2014 are suffering from today? See, Taylor built up his machine thinking at a time when people and work were seen \u2014 at least apparently \u2014 differently. He himself said one of the reasons for his approach was that workers lacked the education or the mental capacity to understand the science behind their own tasks. I guess he was wrong even then, but he is certainly wrong today. Marvin and a lot of unfortunate people are the result of what happens when people are educated and socialized but then end up as part of a machine. Today\u2019s workforce has been \u2014 and increasingly is \u2014 educated to think, judge and take responsibility. See, teaching and learning \u2014 as we will see in one of the next essays \u2014 have made great progress in recent decades. And I\u2019m not talking about higher education; this is true for everybody. Yet our understanding of what most jobs should be has lagged behind. So the gap between what people can do and what their jobs let them do keeps growing. What might have been OK-ish a hundred years ago has grown into a real issue today, with effects on mental health, lost productivity, absenteeism and crippled innovation. And today\u2019s management answer to the issue is still more command \u2014 return to office and other observation methods, as seen in a past essay \u2014 and control \u2014 bonuses and penalties.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The serious study of designing jobs that are not stupid \u2014 sorry, enriched \u2014 is at least as old as I am: fifty-one, if you were wondering. J. Richard Hackman and Greg R. Oldham did some of the pioneering studies, together with their colleagues Janson and Purdy, who worked as consultants for an American insurance company, specifically in a keypunch department. For you younger people, that is data entry onto punch cards, which can then be read by a computer. And for the even younger ones, data entry is what you needed to do before you could just take a picture of something and your smartphone would turn it into machine-readable data. Now, punching cards sounds like a really dull job. But remember, we don\u2019t want exciting, simply not stupid. And the way these people had to work initially was pretty stupid. They were given batches of documents without knowing whom they came from or what they meant. Anyway, even getting that information would have meant nothing, because they were separated from the rest of the company. They were not allowed to correct anything, even if mistakes were obvious. Every card was checked by somebody else, which took almost as long as producing it. If there was an error, it went to a random person for correction; the person who had made the mistake never learned about it. This resulted in what you might expect. The supervisor\u2019s job was constant firefighting. Absence peaked around weekends. Salary complaints came almost daily. The mood was apathetic or hostile. Turnover was low only because jobs elsewhere were scarce and the workforce was settled, not because people were happy. When Hackman and Oldham\u2019s team surveyed the workers, supervisors and checkers, the result was devastating. The job scored poorly on every aspect: little variety, no whole piece of work, no visible meaning. What our psychologically savvy consultants did was assign each operator fixed accounts \u2014 internal clients who provide the documents. The operators got the additional task of checking documents for errors before punching. When they ran into mistakes or problems, they could contact the client directly \u2014 not via a supervisor, as before. Cards were still checked, but faulty ones went back to the original operator for rework. They also got the freedom to set their own working hours \u2014 as long as deadlines were met. Over time, operators who had proven proficient could skip the outside check of their work. The study also had a control group that kept working the old way, and the results were pretty impressive: productivity rose by almost 40%, compared with 8% in the control group; absenteeism fell by a quarter while it rose by almost a third in the control group; and job satisfaction rose by about 16%, against practically nothing in the control group. The error rate dropped by about a third, and the company estimated that the fewer checks saved the equivalent of about seven operators. Supervisors were freed up to actually manage their teams instead of firefighting. This is just one example of many job enrichment studies. What makes it so interesting is that keypunching is really not an exciting job, but with a few organizational changes it can be made into a not-stupid job.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Generally speaking, levers for job enrichment should meet the three needs we established. First come competence and the meaning of what you do. Work should be grouped into natural work units. What\u2019s important is the perspective: natural work units from the point of view of the person doing the work. We still mostly take other perspectives: the technology \u2014 however the machine or the software works best; training \u2014 the smallest steps anyone can learn quickly; the industrial engineer \u2014 the most efficient motion; or workload balancing \u2014 spreading batches evenly. And believe me, the last two I was taught and then taught others for years.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">This is connected to the second lever, combining tasks \u2014 also for competence and meaning. In Taylorism, the idea was to break work down into the smallest possible steps. But that means a worker only knows how to put in one particular screw. More different tasks mean more skills used and mastered, plus you see more of the whole result. Taylor\u2019s argument against that is the same one we still hear today: efficiency. But Hackman and Oldham pointed out, correctly, that you have to consider all the costs. A fragmented job might produce more output \u2014 each step is short, quick to learn and fast to do \u2014 but what you forget are higher turnover, absenteeism, mistakes, extra checking and coordination. These costs often don\u2019t sit in the same cost center and are therefore lost in the calculation.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">We call the process of moving authority \u2014 planning, deciding how, checking your own work, solving problems first \u2014 down into the job vertical loading. It is the exact opposite of what Taylor did: he wanted to move much of it up into management. Vertical loading also needs to be distinguished from what the great Frederick Herzberg \u2014 remember, the guy with pay being just a hygiene factor \u2014 called horizontal loading. That doesn\u2019t work, because it just means the worker has to do more of the same stuff he is already doing \u2014 20,000 bolts instead of 10,000.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Deadlines are part of every job, too. And these, like any kind of rule, can be either informational or controlling. Now, organizations \u2014 because they need some organizing \u2014 have to set a lot of the what, when and why. The reason, of course, is that they need to coordinate different work streams \u2014 less so if you combine tasks naturally, as seen above. The how, however, should be up to the people. Meaning: how these deadlines are met is up to the people actually doing the work. This is often also where efficiency gains come from. Because, let me tell you a bedtime story. Once upon a time, there was a young law student in need of money, so he went out into the wild lands of the corporation and found a job as a data entry clerk. Every afternoon after his lectures, he had to sit in front of a computer and enter numbers from an Excel spreadsheet into a terminal emulation program for an ancient accounting system. This work was so mind-bogglingly stupid that the young student soon had enough and set out to slay the dragon of corporate boredom. In the time he was supposed to play human data interface, he learned enough Visual Basic for Applications to mostly automate his task. That was, of course, yours truly, and my very first professional process improvement.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">And here I see a connection to law again. Remember, in the last essay we said that rules are generalizations, so they need interpretation to match the particular case. Similar thing here. You see, rules work like goals \u2014 or deadlines. They need a reason: enough reason so you know why, but also so you are able to fill in the how. In law, you often have to fill in the how yourself \u2014 or the judge has to. Art. 1 of the Swiss Civil Code (ZGB) names \u201cWortlaut oder Auslegung\u201d \u2014 wording or interpretation \u2014 and, only where neither the law nor customary law provides a rule, lets the judge decide \u201cnach der Regel \u2026, die es als Gesetzgeber aufstellen w\u00fcrde\u201d \u2014 according to the rule the court would set if it were the legislator. Art. 2 ZGB even puts good faith (Treu und Glauben) as a guiding principle above the individual rules. Rules given with a meaningful rationale and room to decide how to comply do not hurt autonomy. In law, this is a core idea. Interpretation is part of every legal professional\u2019s work. And in language, \u201cDienst nach Vorschrift\u201d \u2014 working to rule \u2014 carries the negative: when we don\u2019t have room, and don\u2019t understand or ask ourselves about the reason. Because literal compliance stops work. The authority to interpret belongs where the work is done.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Now a word on quality and feedback. We have come a long way in quality management since the days of Taylorism. We have realized that inspection is a shitty way of managing it. It\u2019s costly, it\u2019s usually just duct-taping, and nobody learns anything, because quality becomes somebody else\u2019s job. We also know that jobs based on machine thinking require a lot more verification to maintain quality. The best approach today is to work with what is called informational feedback, which helps you understand how you\u2019re doing and how you can improve, while controlling feedback pressures you to act in a certain predefined way. This also helps you keep your sense of autonomy. But this is more of a side note, since feedback from the outside is not the job itself, and even the most informative feedback doesn\u2019t make a stupid job any less stupid. But feedback can also be part of the job. That is when you react to and improve the quality of your own work \u2014 but the job needs to be designed for it. You need to get the customer complaints or feedback that refer to your work. You need to see and react to measurements of your work, which, by the way, is the best use of any measurement. Then measurement is the source of real improvement, not bonus pressure.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">A lever for connectedness is client relationships. To feel connected in a work environment, people have to see what their work does and where it creates value. And where do we see that? Yes, exactly, you remember: with the customer \u2014 external or internal. So things like employees knowing who uses their work, direct contact with customers, and agreement on specifications \u2014 on what good looks like \u2014 are extremely important. In addition, this also helps quality management, because people experience quality firsthand.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">So how are jobs supposed to be designed? What is the process? Well, we\u2019re talking about needs like autonomy, competence and connectedness. You think hiring a bunch of consultants to create a couple of PowerPoints with ready-made template job descriptions is the best way to do it? Not really, of course. Consultants are not necessarily a bad idea, but they need to diagnose the as-is jobs together with the people actually doing them. Because the whole thing with the needs already starts at the beginning. It\u2019s always the same \u2014 job design, process problems, planning: the people who do the job have the most insight.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The next lever has more to do with the manager than with the job itself. Because the manager sets the climate, and for Deci and Ryan that comes first. A controlling climate makes even good measures feel like control, and a supportive one makes people read the same measures as information. In an interesting experiment, a controlling style left people with less intrinsic motivation than a supportive one, whether or not rewards were involved. So a manager can make things better or worse even inside a pay system they didn\u2019t choose. And all they have to change is their management style. And this can be learned, by the way \u2014 yes, Deci and Ryan even have a study for that, together with James Connell. Managers in a large US company were trained in just three things: seeing things from their employees\u2019 point of view; giving feedback that informs rather than judges \u2014 and also asking for feedback in return; and supporting initiative, choice and participation. Compared with a control group, the trained managers measurably changed their style. The effects on their employees were less clear-cut, but trust in the company went up \u2014 and the researchers suggest that the direct boss is how employees experience the whole company \u2014 think culture.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">On a day-to-day basis, a supportive management style includes giving reasons for rules and deadlines, using less controlling language \u2014 \u201ccould\u201d instead of \u201cmust\u201d \u2014 and acknowledging when something is annoying instead of pretending all is fine \u2014 remember the guerrilla manager. Plus, managers have to be present. But be very aware that these things are not just tools; they have to come from real interest in and respect for people. If it is just a way to manipulate people, they will notice, because people are not stupid either.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Some supervisors and managers fear that vertical loading takes too much authority away from them. Actually, I have seen that most of them are so overloaded that they can never do what they are supposed to be doing according to their job description: managing people. This overload and pressure is also one of the main reasons why controlling management styles are still used so much. It is what they get from above, it is what they know, and it\u2019s often a short-term fix. So we have to take managers\u2019 and supervisors\u2019 fear of losing something seriously, but they actually have enough of a job already. They just need to be reminded of it.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">How you change is also important. The studies I found showed no bad reaction to job enrichment from any group of people. Still, the initial demand or appetite for it varies. Not surprisingly, many people who have worked for years in a controlled environment will need time to develop their wish for growth, because their drive has been switched off by stupid jobs. We have seen that in past essays, too. Disengaged workers are not the result of a character flaw; they are often made by their jobs. So change \u2014 as always \u2014 should be handled carefully. It\u2019s always best to offer, to show the benefit and to show that you are serious. Do not impose this on people; let it grow within your organization. That brings me to another side note: the term I keep using in this essay is meant seriously \u2014 we want \u201cnot stupid\u201d jobs. You can overdo it: too much variety, too much responsibility and pressure in one job. So at the beginning, really just aim for \u201cnot stupid\u201d and make sure the three needs are met.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Wait, wait, you will say \u2014 all of this is fine, but the real motivator is pay, right? You are not willing to work if you are not paid for it. Pay is indeed the elephant in the room in this essay. For the simple reason that this is an essay about motivation, and pay doesn\u2019t belong here \u2014 the same way an elephant doesn\u2019t belong in a room. Pay belongs in the wild lands of economics. See, motivation is all about psychological needs; pay is about physiological needs. Makes sense? I see I haven\u2019t sold you on this one yet.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">But there is good proof for it. First, there is something called crowding out. See, the economist\u2019s view is that motivation simply adds up. If people already do something for their own reasons and you add money, you get the old reason plus the money \u2014 so more motivation and more effort. Crowding out says the two interact. Money can replace the existing reason rather than add to it, so total motivation can go down. This goes back to an experiment Deci did with students who were paid to solve puzzles. They lost interest in the puzzles once the payments stopped. Unpaid students, on the other hand, stayed interested. The background is that rewards change who owns the reason. If I do it because it matters, I own the reason. If you pay me to do it, you may end up owning the reason. Bruno S. Frey and Felix Oberholzer-Gee did a survey in 1993 in two communities in Switzerland where a repository for radioactive waste was planned. Without any compensation, about 50% would accept the site in their community. With compensation \u2014 and the amount was varied \u2014 acceptance fell to about 25%. The amount barely mattered; that was checked. A repeat survey in six communities being considered for a second site showed a similar result. Without the money, civic duty and a fair siting procedure went hand in hand with acceptance. Once money entered the discussion, those effects disappeared. This is not an isolated finding \u2014 the same crowding-out effect has been documented in studies across very different contexts, from puzzles in the lab to real-life decisions like the waste site.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">You might counter these studies with what Edward P. Lazear found when he studied a US company switching from fixed hourly pay to piece rates \u2014 with a guaranteed minimum, I have to add, to be fair. His study showed that productivity rose by 44%, while on average pay rose by 7% \u2014 so most of the gain actually stayed with the company. But anyhow, this shows that piece pay can raise output on simple work you can count. I have to admit that. But Lazear himself limits the result: in the case he studied, output was easily countable, quality problems could be readily detected, and blame \u2014 and the work to correct it \u2014 could be directly assigned. And don\u2019t even get me started on the fact that piece pay doesn\u2019t take problems of supply and demand into consideration. If supply gets restricted or demand drops because of some external event \u2014 volcanoes, diseases, wars, normal market fluctuations \u2014 workers have no influence over their output and pay. Yes, the guaranteed minimum can take care of physiological needs like paying the bills, but whatever motivating effect piece pay was supposed to have is gone. Lazear also said that piecework is not always profitable. He saw that kind of reward system as best suited to independent production jobs. Managerial or professional work, he cautioned, cannot be measured the same way. One reason is that with interdependent work, output is harder to count and quality problems are harder to assign. So all he found is that reward systems might work for simple work you can count, but probably not for managers. And most knowledge work, service work and managerial work fails these three conditions \u2014 which is exactly the work most of you people reading this do. Oh, by the way, who usually gets the big performance bonus in your company?<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">And that is where the problem only begins. Once you start paying any kind of monetary incentive, you can\u2019t easily take it back. There are two reasons for that. First, crowded-out intrinsic motivation doesn\u2019t simply come back once you stop the incentive. Multiple studies have shown exactly that. Second, people come to perceive a bonus as income. So if you regularly pay out something \u2014 even a varying sum \u2014 it is not perceived as an extra. It becomes part of your normal pay. Take it away and it\u2019s a pay cut \u2014 that\u2019s Herzberg\u2019s hygiene factor again: it doesn\u2019t add anything positive while it\u2019s there, but remove it and it\u2019s perceived as a loss. So even if you take my advice and get rid of incentives, you won\u2019t save the money, because you still have to pay it. You save everything but that: the cost of your incentive system \u2014 you know, the hours of evaluations and measuring and conversations and all that jazz. Still, I advise doing it. Get rid of all bonuses and reward systems other than a chocolate at Christmas. You will have to raise base salaries, but you lose a lot of bureaucratic hassle and cost. You remove one big source of crowding out, so intrinsic motivation has a much better chance of staying intact. And you get rid of all that stupid number-playing with bonus-linked targets and KPIs that brings the organization exactly zero. And of course, if you are really lucky and don\u2019t have an incentive system in your company, never, ever, in a million years start one.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">And I know that sales commissions and startup equity have become industry standards, but that doesn\u2019t make them right. Yes, sales commissions can be considered piece work, but only if the product or service is a very simple one and does not require a lot of implementation work. And equity can also be taken as a form of profit sharing, but let\u2019s get to that in a moment. So, leave them if you don\u2019t see an alternative payment model, but don\u2019t fool yourself into believing that these will solve all the motivation problems in your organization. The rule still holds: no stupid jobs.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Still feeling uncomfortable talking about this? Well, let me try to ease your mind. Look at it this way: you and I and all other workers should be paid for exactly what we do \u2014 work \u2014 not for the outcome of a usually very complex production or service process that depends on the performance of all the employees and is influenced by social, political and whatever other circumstances. And if that hasn\u2019t eased your mind, let me try the reverse and aggravate it a bit: managers should be paid like bureaucrats. That is \u2014 with a \u201cYes\u201d in front \u2014 the title of a 2005 working paper by Frey and Osterloh arguing that, because of neutrality and self-serving bias, managers should get fixed pay. Just like judges, politicians and public officials, managers have to apply rules, and they shouldn\u2019t profit from bending those rules \u2014 you know, like artificially enhancing a bonus-relevant KPI. This is actually our old friend Max Weber\u2019s argument for why bureaucracy works. And it has consequences for the whole organization. Because when employees see that \u201ctheir superiors feather their own nests,\u201d their own willingness to cooperate and stay honest drops considerably. Self-serving bias simply means that it is very hard, even for the most honest person, not to confuse what\u2019s good for others or the organization with what is good for themselves when they have room to move. That\u2019s not corruption; it\u2019s just normal human bias. Fixed pay for managers helps keep decisions neutral and protects the cooperation of everyone below.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Some say that managers simply carry more burden than everybody else in an organization, which is why they deserve a little extra. True, if you can prove you carry more burden, you should be paid for it \u2014 but that proof rarely exists. A middle or lower manager carries as much burden as a top manager. The rest is the leadership mythology we know from the first two essays in this series \u2014 remember the gunslinger? A large US study actually points the other way: supervisors suffered the most from depression and anxiety, and owners no more than ordinary workers. And the theory confirms that. Karasek found that stress comes from demands without control, not from rank.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Look, this discussion leads me to something that is actually the opposite of money as a motivator. The pay gap that exists in most companies is damaging to staff motivation. And the gap has grown wider and wider: Frey and Osterloh report that the CEO-to-worker pay ratio in the US went from about 25 in 1970 to 210 in 1996, and to over 500 by 2000. Taking this and Lazear\u2019s findings into consideration, maybe we should reverse the trend. Profit sharing should be extended to all employees \u2014 remember, you can\u2019t take anything away, not even from the top managers. One study found that firms with profit sharing or company-wide bonuses had about a third lower probability of corporate crime. And there is a good argument for why crowding out doesn\u2019t kick in here. See, workers see the pay gap as something unfair, something negative. Reducing it may not touch intrinsic motivation at all, because it simply removes a negative \u2014 an injustice, so to speak. It\u2019s also important to note that profit sharing is not a bonus. An individual bonus is \u2014 at least supposedly \u2014 based on your own performance. Profit sharing is based on the result of the whole organization.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In the end, however people are paid, they need to be paid fairly, because it is a sign of respect and because it enables people to meet their physiological needs \u2014 you know, getting stuff to eat and such. And that is the answer I promised earlier: working for pay can be experienced as autonomous when the pay is fair, fixed and not tied to performance \u2014 then it supports motivation as a sign of respect. Bonuses rarely do that. But pay itself is no motivator. Strike that from your mind; it doesn\u2019t work.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">To summarize: Taylor saw how much energy people had outside work, then designed jobs that treated them like cogs in a machine. Deci and Ryan helped us see why that switches the energy off. Autonomy, competence and connectedness are the needs that have to be met so we don\u2019t kill our intrinsic motivation. Job enrichment is the lever we can actually pull: give people a whole piece of work, room to decide how to do it, and a chance to see whom it helps. And yes, pay people fairly, because they have to pay bills and deserve respect \u2014 but a bonus won\u2019t make a stupid job any less stupid. Punkt.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Why is this so important? Because we don\u2019t want to end up like Marvin, a depressed robot with a brain the size of a planet, pushed around and shunned by everybody. I can\u2019t promise you that not-stupid jobs will make your company hugely successful in financial terms \u2014 but the evidence suggests they won\u2019t make it worse off. What I can promise you is a lot of happier Marvins working with you. And that also has a cost dimension: \u201cunhappy\u201d is easily and funnily said, but it has a serious component called mental health. And that has an impact on costs, financially and humanly.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Don\u2019t just take it from me, here is some good stuff to read:<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Adams, Douglas. The Hitchhiker\u2019s Guide to the Galaxy. London: Pan Books, 1979.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Adams, Douglas. The Restaurant at the End of the Universe. London: Pan Books, 1980.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Deming, W. Edwards. Out of the Crisis. Cambridge, MA: MIT Center for Advanced Engineering Study, 1986.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Frey, Bruno S., and Felix Oberholzer-Gee. \u201cThe Cost of Price Incentives: An Empirical Analysis of Motivation Crowding-Out.\u201d American Economic Review 87, no. 4 (1997): 746\u201355.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Frey, Bruno S., and Margit Osterloh. \u201cYes, Managers Should Be Paid Like Bureaucrats.\u201d CESifo Working Paper no. 1379, 2005.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Graeber, David. Bullshit Jobs: A Theory. New York: Simon &amp; Schuster, 2018.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Hackman, J. Richard, Greg Oldham, Robert Janson, and Kenneth Purdy. \u201cA New Strategy for Job Enrichment.\u201d California Management Review 17, no. 4 (1975): 57\u201371.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Herzberg, Frederick. \u201cOne More Time: How Do You Motivate Employees?\u201d Harvard Business Review 46, no. 1 (1968): 53\u201362.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Lazear, Edward P. \u201cPerformance Pay and Productivity.\u201d American Economic Review 90, no. 5 (2000): 1346\u201361.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Locke, Edwin A., and Gary P. Latham. \u201cBuilding a Practically Useful Theory of Goal Setting and Task Motivation: A 35-Year Odyssey.\u201d American Psychologist 57, no. 9 (2002): 705\u201317.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Ryan, Richard M., and Edward L. Deci. Self-Determination Theory: Basic Psychological Needs in Motivation, Development, and Wellness. New York: Guilford Press, 2017.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Soffia, Magdalena, Alex J. Wood, and Brendan Burchell. \u201cAlienation Is Not \u2018Bullshit\u2019: An Empirical Critique of Graeber\u2019s Theory of BS Jobs.\u201d Work, Employment and Society 36, no. 5 (2022): 816\u201340.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Taylor, Frederick Winslow. The Principles of Scientific Management. New York: Harper &amp; Brothers, 1911.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Or How to Design Not-Stupid Jobs OK, I might not have a brain the size of a planet like Marvin \u2014 you know, the robot from The Hitchhiker\u2019s Guide to the Galaxy, for all of you ignorant Vogons \u2014 but he was always the character I felt for most in the story. And no, Douglas, [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":284,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paid_content":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[35],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-283","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-conversation-with-the-caterpillar-en"],"jetpack_featured_media_url":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/11\/brain-the-size-of-a-planet.png","jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/283","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=283"}],"version-history":[{"count":1,"href":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/283\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":285,"href":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/283\/revisions\/285"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/media\/284"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=283"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=283"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/markusstettler.com\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=283"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}